主管:中华人民共和国司法部
主办:司法鉴定科学研究院
ISSN 1671-2072  CN 31-1863/N

中国司法鉴定 ›› 2023 ›› Issue (4): 1-9.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1671-2072.2023.04.001

• 鉴定制度 •    下一篇

监管场所死亡事件中死因鉴定的检察监督路径

张 栋,韩卓韦   

  1. 华东政法大学 刑事法学院,上海 201620
  • 收稿日期:2022-10-08 出版日期:2023-07-15 发布日期:2023-07-16
  • 作者简介:张栋(1971—),男,教授,博士,博士研究生导师,主要从事刑事诉讼法研究。E-mail: dong_ch@126.com

The Path of Procuratorial Supervision on the Identification of Death Cause in the Event of Regulatory Place Death

ZHANG Dong, HAN Zhuowei   

  1. Criminal Justice College, East China University of Political Science and Law, Shanghai 201620, China
  • Received:2022-10-08 Published:2023-07-15 Online:2023-07-16

摘要: 司法实践中监管场所发生被监管人死亡事件后,死者亲属闹访的现象较为突出。从诉讼法和司法鉴定的角度来看,暴露出的核心问题是调查程序本身存在缺陷,公信力不足致使死因鉴定不能令人信服。目前,我国死因鉴定程序中存在的问题包括监管场所违背回避原则、死亡原因界限不清、检察监督介入较晚、案件情况公开不足等。参考域外死因裁判陪审团制度,结合《关于监管场所被监管人死亡检察程序的规定(征求意见稿)》和若干现行检察制度,我国监管场所被监管人死亡事件的监督路径可以从检察机关独立调查、引入人民监督员实行外部监督、开展检察听证等方面加以完善。

关键词: 死亡事件, 死因鉴定, 死因裁判, 检察监督, 人民监督员

Abstract: In judicial practice, it is common for relatives of the deceased to “make trouble” after a death event occurs in a regulatory place. From the perspective of procedural law and forensic appraisal, the core problem exposed is that the investigation procedure itself has defects, and the lack of credibility makes the appraisal of death cause unconvincing. At present, the problems in the appraisal of death cause procedure in China include the violation of the principle of avoidance by a regulatory place, the blurred the boundary of the death cause, the late involvement of procuratorial supervision, and the insufficient publicity of the case. With reference to the jury system for judging the death cause in foreign countries, in combination with the Provisions on the Prosecutorial Procedure for the Death of the Supervised Person in Regulatory Places (Draft for Comments) and several existing prosecutorial rules, the supervision path of death events in a regulatory place in China can be improved from the aspects of independent investigation by the procuratorial organ, introduction of people’s supervisors to implement external supervision, and conducting procuratorial hearings.

Key words: death event, appraisal of death cause, judgment on death cause, procuratorial supervision, people’s supervisor

中图分类号: