主管:中华人民共和国司法部
主办:司法鉴定科学研究院
ISSN 1671-2072  CN 31-1863/N

中国司法鉴定 ›› 2021 ›› Issue (5): 1-8.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1671-2072.2021.05.001

• 专题研讨:司法鉴定公信力建设 •    下一篇

司法鉴定公信力的内生性基础及其提升路径优选

郭 华   

  1. 中央财经大学 法学院,北京 100081
  • 收稿日期:2021-07-12 出版日期:2021-09-30 发布日期:2021-12-20
  • 作者简介:郭华(1963—),男,教授,博士,博士研究生导师,主要从事诉讼法学、司法制度研究。E-mail:guohua369@sina.com

The Endogenous Basis of the Credibility of Forensic Appraisal and the Optimization of Its Promotion Path

GUO Hua   

  1. Law School, Central University of Finance and Economics, Beijing 100081, China
  • Received:2021-07-12 Published:2021-09-30 Online:2021-12-20

摘要: 司法鉴定在深化其管理体制机制改革进程中出现了公信力不足的困境,增强和提升其公信力成为进一步深化改革亟待解决的问题之一。司法鉴定表面呈现的权威旁落,深层折射出其科学性的信心不足。司法鉴定公信力受制于社会舆论导向、当事人争议以及使用部门评价等诸多方面衍生出的不信任,源于法官过度依赖作为证据的鉴定意见来替代事实裁判引发的负面效应,根植于其可靠性的销蚀和可信性的降低。解决问题,需要从外部减少影响司法鉴定公信力的因子,消除对其认识的偏差和舆论宣传的误导,司法鉴定科学性的内部基础,通过尊重司法鉴定科学性来维护其可信性的向度,获得司法鉴定权威的力量,从而使其公信力得到提升。

关键词: 司法鉴定, 内生性, 可靠性, 权威性, 公信力

Abstract: Forensic appraisal has the problem of insufficient credibility in the process of deepening the reform of its management system and mechanism. Enhancing and improving its credibility have become one of the urgent problems to be solved in the reform. It appears that the authority of forensic appraisal is absent, which in essence reflects the lack of confidence in its scientificity. The credibility of forensic appraisal is subject to a lot of mistrust derived from the steering of public opinion, disputes between the parties and the evaluation of the user department. It stems from the negative effect of excessive reliance by some judges on appraisal opinion as evidence instead of facts finding, and is rooted in the erosion of its reliability and the reduction of its credibility. To solve this problem, we need to reduce the factors affecting the credibility of forensic appraisal from the outside, eliminate the deviation of understanding and the misleading public opinion, build the internal foundation of the scientificity of forensic appraisal, and maintain its credibility by respecting the scientificity of forensic appraisal, so as to obtain the authority of forensic appraisal and improve its credibility.

Key words: forensic appraisal, endogeneity, reliability, authority, credibility

中图分类号: